"Mariano Martinez Peck"<marianopeck@gmail.com> wrote:
Anyway.... I do need encrypt/decrypt and it should be fast. I have just tried ARC4 and seems to be fast. I have a few questions:
- If I make the ARC4 key larger is it likely to be safer? - How does ARC4 compare to blowfish from security point of view? Is blowfish much more secure or not that much?
mmm reading a bit more I would say ARC4 may not be the most accurate for my case. Why? Because I may have many fields from many objects all being protected with the same password (hence, same key for the ARC4). This may affect ARC4 security, right? And even more that key is not a random stream but a fixed one (the " SecureHashAlgorithm new hashMessage: aString" of the password they are protected with)....
With stream ciphers (or block cipher in modes that emulate a stream cipher, e.g. OFB, CTR) you absolutely must not reuse the same key to encrypt different data (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stream_cipher_attack). You could try to devise a way to avoid re-using the exact same key, e.g. generate the encryption key by mixing in a unique id of the field that you're encrypting along with the password, but unless you really know what you're doing, it's quite easy to make a fatal mistake in your design. Best way to do this is to stick with standard solutions. You're trying to use passwords for encryption, so your standard options would be PKCS#5, bcrypt or scrypt. HTH, Martin