Users of UnhandledError definitely shows that it is a critical bug. For example we rely on UnhandledError in Announcer to ensure that all subscriptions will be processed independently on errors signalled by any of them: ann := Announcer new. ann when: ValueChanged do: [:ann | 1 logCr. 1/0 ]. ann when: ValueChanged do: [:ann | 2 logCr. 2/0 ]. ann when: ValueChanged do: [:ann | 3 logCr. 3/0 ]. ann announce: ValueChanged new It will show 1, 2, 3 in transcript and open 3 debuggers. Each error is deferred to the background process allowing the delivery to continue: AnnouncementSubscription>>deliver: anAnnouncement " deliver an announcement to receiver. In case of failure, it will be handled in separate process" ^ (self handlesAnnouncement: anAnnouncement ) ifTrue: [ [action cull: anAnnouncement cull: announcer] on: UnhandledError fork: [:ex | ex pass ]] Now if you will try to wrap #announce: into handler block the deliver will be interrupted by first error: [ann announce: ValueChanged new] on: ZeroDivide do: [ :err | err logCr. err pass ]. It will open single debugger at first handler error. ÑÑ, 18 дек. 2019 г. в 20:44, Denis Kudriashov <dionisiydk@gmail.com>:
Hi.
I played a bit with exceptions trying to detect that given block will open the debugger. My idea was to simply catch UnhandledError which normally means that no outer code handles given error and therefore debugger is appeared. For my surprise the following example works from playground but not from the browser editor:
[MyTestError signal ] on: UnhandledError do: [ :e | self halt ]
In playground you will see the halt. But from the browser the debugger will show MyTestError.
After breaking my head I found that there is a difference how scripts are executed in those tools. In Playground it is a deferred action. But in the browser it is evaluated as a deep event processing code (keymap processing) and there is an outer error handler (on: Error do: ) which does some work and passes the exception further (err pass). Following script demonstrates the difference in the error processing logic when there is an outer handler:
[
[MyTestError signal ] on: UnhandledError do: [ :e | self halt ]
] on: MyTestError do: [ :z | z pass]
Try it from playground. Second line separately will show the halt while all together it will stop at MyTestError signal.
Debugging shows that when the outer handler is processed it sets the handler context into the exception and it skips the existing handler for UnhandledError.
The question: is it a feature or a bug? Think also how following code should work (unrelated to UnhandledError logic):
[
[ 1/0 ] on: MyTestError do: [ :e | self halt ]
] on: ZeroDivide do: [ :z | MyTestError signal ]
Currently it will show MyTestError signal.
Best regards, Denis