On Fri, Feb 25, 2011 at 2:10 PM, Torsten Bergmann <astares@gmx.de> wrote:
Markus wrote:
The XML package breaks the build? So let's remove it completely. Let's ship >1.2, but without all the packages that are problematic.
It's not that the package is problematic - the Configs are problematic
Laurent wrote:
For XML I can fix this tonight if Otto don't want / can do it.
Yes, the problematic 1.1.8 version of XMLSupport has to be fixed. But it is not yet used by Pharo ... so this is not the reason:
What strikes me is that ConfigurationOfPharo STILL references the working 1.1.6 version BUT the corrupt 1.1.8 version is loaded instead.
May be another ConfigurationOfXXXX reference XMLSupport ? Laurent
THIS is the reason why Hudson is read!
If you look at ConfigurationOfPharo then it hasnt changed since 18 February 2011 (ConfigurationOfPharo-GuillermoPolito.134) and if you load "ConfigurationOfXMLSupport-DaleHenrichs.46" from 9 February 2011 and check what Otto Behrens changed then you will notice that he did'nt touch the 1.1.6 version of ConfigurationOfXMLSupport.
He just added a baseline/version 1.1.8 and 1.1.9.
So the "old" version 1.1.6 which is used by ConfigurationOfPharo was not touched either.
To me this looks like a Metacello resolving remote project versions problem? (that's why I CC:ed Dale)
But I agree that it seems few people care about 1.2. Sad, I like it far better than 1.1.1.
Yes, but I think we opened 1.3 too early. I think thats why community does not concentrate on Pharo dev 1.2 too much and continues to work on 1.3 core instead.
Thats good for moving Pharo forward - but not for outside visibility. How should others deliver software on top of Pharo if Pharo isnt delivered itself?
I personally thing if we ever want to release 1.2, we need to start to be more radical.
Yes - but not by throwing out broken packages. What if Hudson is broken by a problem in clas Object. Would you throw out Kernel?
Instead I would propose for the harvesters/integrators to stop integrating stuff for 1.3 until Pharo 1.2 is out of the door...
Bye T. -- Empfehlen Sie GMX DSL Ihren Freunden und Bekannten und wir belohnen Sie mit bis zu 50,- Euro! https://freundschaftswerbung.gmx.de