It seems like a bug to me, but perhaps I misunderstand something.

1) Comment in Rectangle class >> origin:corner: method shows 'origin' should be top left and 'corner' should be bottom right. This method calls Rectangle >> setPoint:point:. But this method calculates 'origin' to be bottom left corner and 'corner' to be top right. Now all the edge and corner methods are wrong.

r := Rectangle origin: 0@0 corner: 10@10.

r topLeft. ��=> (0@0) �� "should be 0@10"

r bottomRight. ��=> (10@10) ��"should be 10@0"

r top. ��=> 0 ��"should be 10"

r bottom. ��=> 10 ��" should be 0"

2) Why Polygon >> bounds (which is PathShape >> bounds) returns a rectangle with a corner 1 point larger than the actual boundary?

p1 := Polygon vertices: {0@0 . 0@10 . 10@10 . 10@0}.

p1 bounds. ��=> (0@0) corner: (11@11). ��"should be 0@0 and 10@10"

This seems to be a fix to Rectangle >> containsPoint: strange behavior. By strange behavior, I mean:

r := Rectangle point: 0@0 point: 10@10.

r containsPoint: 0@0. ��=> true

r containsPoint: 10@10. ��=> false ��"should be true"

{ r topLeft . r topRight . r bottomLeft . r bottomRight } allSatisfy [ :corner | r containsPoint: corner ]. ��=> false ��"should be true"

I want to fix this in my image, but Rectangle is used all over the place and I'm worry I'll break a lot of things. I wonder if I just misunderstood how these are supposed to be used. Can anybody help me understand if this is intentional or a bug?

PS: I looked at RectangleTest and I'm not sure I understand why they are testing what they are testing.

--

Andreas Sunardi