Hi Guille - thanks for Chipping in on this - I have bookmarked the revert commands you have mentioned and see if that works better for me (rather than flailing around and making a mess of it). Possibly this scenario is one that could get its own menu option in the future - its a quite a common thing to want to just get bak to a safe point.

For the cherry picking - I have raised an Issue (in Iceberg?) - https://github.com/pharo-vcs/iceberg/issues/1519

Tim

On 28 Jun 2021, at 13:12, Guillermo Polito <guillermopolito@gmail.com> wrote:

Hi Tim,

El 22 jun 2021, a las 1:39, Tim Mackinnon <tim@testit.works> escribi��:

Hi guys - while I mostly get along with Iceberg and can do common stuff - there are still a few things that I'm not sure on the best way to work.

A recent one, was that I created a branch for an experiment - decided not to use and then went back to master to try again. However if I want to cherry pick code (particularly a few methods) - is there nothing I can use to do this easily? I can browse the branch in the repo explorer and see diffs of methods to master - but why can't I load any of those methods (or am I missing something obvious here?)

This seems to be a feature that was not migrated in the iceberg-to-spec2 migration.
Would you mind opening an issue?


The other item that still confuses me today - how can I easily revert back to previous point in time, essentially undo work I've commited and possible pushed to my git repo. I also struggle with this one - end up with a detached head and flail around. I don't understand why this is so hard to do - and can only think its because everything is based on graphs of graphs and so there is the potential that going back in time can break this? Anyway - what is the foolproof way to go back to the older point, and then start coding so that this becomes the new Head?

There are two different questions in here.

- How can you go back to some older commit?

In iceberg this is done by creating a new branch from the commit you���re interested in. The ���Branch������ menu will open a pop-up to allow you creating a new branch from that point in time.
Then you can checkout that branch and work as with any other branch.

<PastedGraphic-5.png>


- How can you undo some history (that was even pushed)?

Iceberg does not support this scenario yet, as it could be very problematic when working in teams.
Undoing some history / removing some commit will produce undesired effects on people that had pulled that commit.
This is one of the scenarios that in git requires a `���force` flag.

If you want to do such a thing, you need for now to do it from the command line

```sh
$ git reset ���hard THE_COMMIT_ID_YOU_WANT_TO_GO_BACK_TO
$ git push -f
```

And then checkout the branch back from iceberg (which will show a detached working copy ��� see https://books.pharo.org/booklet-ManageCode/pdf/2020-05-12-ManageCode.pdf).

G


Pointers on these two items greatly appreciate for my road to vcs greatness (and gosh I mess Envy - as I haven't asked about showing me deleted "available methods" and "classes")

Tim