On Jan 1, 2010, at 14:16 , Stephan Eggermont wrote:

Adrian wrote:

...

What about using a wiki to gather and edit comments (as suggested by Stan) and then integrate them in a second step so that they are kept together with the code (as suggested by Stef)? Just a thought...

I'd very much prefer an in-image solution and avoid integrating.

What I suggested is an in-image solution, just that the contribution is done via a wiki from which the text is then integrated (i.e., copied or even moved). The alternative would be that people directly write comments in a Pharo image and then commit changes to the inbox. The wiki may work out better because it is simpler to add and edit contributions. Either way you need to integrate. Somehow the changes need to get into the PharoCore and we want to have review what gets in.

In-image we have much better version info, and much better browsing available.

Yes. As Lukas pointed out in another mail, one major difficulty is to get contributions. Unless we have a few people that regularly commit time to writing and reviewing comments, we won't make progress... Cheers, Adrian