Anyone here run a web app using plain ZnServer (or subclasses) on a cheap VPS (i.e., $10/month DO droplet or equivalent). What are your experiences?, suggestions. I am planning a web app with just plain ZnServer, SQLite3, ATS or equivalent. Thanks, Vince

Hi Vince, That is certainly possible and works well. I would recommend an instance with 1GB RAM, that leaves you some headroom. Deploying web applications is of course a broad subject, much of the required knowledge is not Pharo specific, but needed anyway. The last chapter in the Pharo Enterprise book (https://books.pharo.org/enterprise-pharo/) is a good starting point (Deployment). But there are other and different approaches. A plain HTTP demo instance running on a DO instance can be found here: http://zn.stfx.eu/welcome For production use you should front with NGINX or something similar to add HTTPS. May people on this mailing list deploy Pharo server applications, we have tens of them in day to day production doing real work. Good luck on your journey, you know where to ask questions. Regards, Sven > On 22 Jul 2021, at 07:56, vinref@gmail.com wrote: > > Anyone here run a web app using plain ZnServer (or subclasses) on a cheap VPS (i.e., $10/month DO droplet or equivalent). What are your experiences?, suggestions. > > I am planning a web app with just plain ZnServer, SQLite3, ATS or equivalent. > > Thanks, Vince >

Yeap, not much more to add than what Sven said. What's important to mention is that they are really stable. I've been running Pharo servers in DO droplets of all sizes, without issues (some running for months), I only had to upscale one droplet to more memory, and it was because of a leak I introduced with PGSQL connections, otherwise, they're pretty lightweight for today's standards and a normal workload. I have deployments with nginx and Pharo images as upstreams, and I have one with Docker swarm and Traefik doing the load balancing among different Pharo workers and acting as the HTTPS endpoint. I'm removing this option though and moving back to nginx only. What I never tried was to host a docker container running Pharo, in some Docker hosting. It might be the best option as a quick start, but after doing the math, it's always more expensive than a Droplet. Best regards, Esteban A. Maringolo On Thu, Jul 22, 2021 at 3:21 AM Sven Van Caekenberghe <sven@stfx.eu> wrote: > > Hi Vince, > > That is certainly possible and works well. I would recommend an instance with 1GB RAM, that leaves you some headroom. > > Deploying web applications is of course a broad subject, much of the required knowledge is not Pharo specific, but needed anyway. > > The last chapter in the Pharo Enterprise book (https://books.pharo.org/enterprise-pharo/) is a good starting point (Deployment). But there are other and different approaches. > > A plain HTTP demo instance running on a DO instance can be found here: http://zn.stfx.eu/welcome > > For production use you should front with NGINX or something similar to add HTTPS. > > May people on this mailing list deploy Pharo server applications, we have tens of them in day to day production doing real work. > > Good luck on your journey, you know where to ask questions. > > Regards, > > Sven > > > On 22 Jul 2021, at 07:56, vinref@gmail.com wrote: > > > > Anyone here run a web app using plain ZnServer (or subclasses) on a cheap VPS (i.e., $10/month DO droplet or equivalent). What are your experiences?, suggestions. > > > > I am planning a web app with just plain ZnServer, SQLite3, ATS or equivalent. > > > > Thanks, Vince > >

Yes, very stable. I've had a DigitalOcean droplet running for 6 years that was holding various false starts. To my surprise, one (never "shipped") website was still running (Pharo-3.?, mongodb, Bootstrap css). I'd been poking the site every once in a while, and found that the Bootstrap UI steadily degraded, because I'd pointed the site's .css at some non-fixed version from some CDN server (so that .css must have changed over the years). The uptime on the machine was over 1000 days, and there have been many emails over the years about network, hardware, etc. changes. After years of unattended reboots, some relic was still up. Anyhow, that instance is now deleted, probably soon to be joined by a more recent setup where I started with the DO 1-click docker droplet. This setup was useful to learn about docker, and I might go back to it in the future. Given Estaban's comments in this thread, I decided to do a bare nginx + Pharo image deployment (which is similar to the now deleted 6 year instance described above, which had Apache2 instead of nginx). I will have the mongo server on a separate machine, but have not decided whether to use the DO offering of a managed mongo server. It's still a work in progress, and other's experiences are of interest. Thanks for reading. Yanni Chiu On Thu, Jul 22, 2021 at 8:33 AM Esteban Maringolo <emaringolo@gmail.com> wrote: > > Yeap, not much more to add than what Sven said. What's important to > mention is that they are really stable. > I've been running Pharo servers in DO droplets of all sizes, without > issues (some running for months), I only had to upscale one droplet to > more memory, and it was because of a leak I introduced with PGSQL > connections, otherwise, they're pretty lightweight for today's > standards and a normal workload. > > I have deployments with nginx and Pharo images as upstreams, and I > have one with Docker swarm and Traefik doing the load balancing among > different Pharo workers and acting as the HTTPS endpoint. I'm removing > this option though and moving back to nginx only. > > What I never tried was to host a docker container running Pharo, in > some Docker hosting. It might be the best option as a quick start, but > after doing the math, it's always more expensive than a Droplet. > > Best regards, > > Esteban A. Maringolo > > On Thu, Jul 22, 2021 at 3:21 AM Sven Van Caekenberghe <sven@stfx.eu> wrote: > > > > Hi Vince, > > > > That is certainly possible and works well. I would recommend an instance with 1GB RAM, that leaves you some headroom. > > > > Deploying web applications is of course a broad subject, much of the required knowledge is not Pharo specific, but needed anyway. > > > > The last chapter in the Pharo Enterprise book (https://books.pharo.org/enterprise-pharo/) is a good starting point (Deployment). But there are other and different approaches. > > > > A plain HTTP demo instance running on a DO instance can be found here: http://zn.stfx.eu/welcome > > > > For production use you should front with NGINX or something similar to add HTTPS. > > > > May people on this mailing list deploy Pharo server applications, we have tens of them in day to day production doing real work. > > > > Good luck on your journey, you know where to ask questions. > > > > Regards, > > > > Sven > > > > > On 22 Jul 2021, at 07:56, vinref@gmail.com wrote: > > > > > > Anyone here run a web app using plain ZnServer (or subclasses) on a cheap VPS (i.e., $10/month DO droplet or equivalent). What are your experiences?, suggestions. > > > > > > I am planning a web app with just plain ZnServer, SQLite3, ATS or equivalent. > > > > > > Thanks, Vince > > >

HI Yanni, Thanks for sharing your experience report! Sven > On 27 Jul 2021, at 01:53, Yanni Chiu <yannix7db@gmail.com> wrote: > > Yes, very stable. I've had a DigitalOcean droplet running for 6 years > that was holding various false starts. To my surprise, one (never > "shipped") website was still running (Pharo-3.?, mongodb, Bootstrap > css). I'd been poking the site every once in a while, and found that > the Bootstrap UI steadily degraded, because I'd pointed the site's > .css at some non-fixed version from some CDN server (so that .css must > have changed over the years). The uptime on the machine was over 1000 > days, and there have been many emails over the years about network, > hardware, etc. changes. After years of unattended reboots, some relic > was still up. > > Anyhow, that instance is now deleted, probably soon to be joined by a > more recent setup where I started with the DO 1-click docker droplet. > This setup was useful to learn about docker, and I might go back to it > in the future. Given Estaban's comments in this thread, I decided to > do a bare nginx + Pharo image deployment (which is similar to the now > deleted 6 year instance described above, which had Apache2 instead of > nginx). I will have the mongo server on a separate machine, but have > not decided whether to use the DO offering of a managed mongo server. > It's still a work in progress, and other's experiences are of > interest. > > Thanks for reading. > Yanni Chiu > > On Thu, Jul 22, 2021 at 8:33 AM Esteban Maringolo <emaringolo@gmail.com> wrote: >> >> Yeap, not much more to add than what Sven said. What's important to >> mention is that they are really stable. >> I've been running Pharo servers in DO droplets of all sizes, without >> issues (some running for months), I only had to upscale one droplet to >> more memory, and it was because of a leak I introduced with PGSQL >> connections, otherwise, they're pretty lightweight for today's >> standards and a normal workload. >> >> I have deployments with nginx and Pharo images as upstreams, and I >> have one with Docker swarm and Traefik doing the load balancing among >> different Pharo workers and acting as the HTTPS endpoint. I'm removing >> this option though and moving back to nginx only. >> >> What I never tried was to host a docker container running Pharo, in >> some Docker hosting. It might be the best option as a quick start, but >> after doing the math, it's always more expensive than a Droplet. >> >> Best regards, >> >> Esteban A. Maringolo >> >> On Thu, Jul 22, 2021 at 3:21 AM Sven Van Caekenberghe <sven@stfx.eu> wrote: >>> >>> Hi Vince, >>> >>> That is certainly possible and works well. I would recommend an instance with 1GB RAM, that leaves you some headroom. >>> >>> Deploying web applications is of course a broad subject, much of the required knowledge is not Pharo specific, but needed anyway. >>> >>> The last chapter in the Pharo Enterprise book (https://books.pharo.org/enterprise-pharo/) is a good starting point (Deployment). But there are other and different approaches. >>> >>> A plain HTTP demo instance running on a DO instance can be found here: http://zn.stfx.eu/welcome >>> >>> For production use you should front with NGINX or something similar to add HTTPS. >>> >>> May people on this mailing list deploy Pharo server applications, we have tens of them in day to day production doing real work. >>> >>> Good luck on your journey, you know where to ask questions. >>> >>> Regards, >>> >>> Sven >>> >>>> On 22 Jul 2021, at 07:56, vinref@gmail.com wrote: >>>> >>>> Anyone here run a web app using plain ZnServer (or subclasses) on a cheap VPS (i.e., $10/month DO droplet or equivalent). What are your experiences?, suggestions. >>>> >>>> I am planning a web app with just plain ZnServer, SQLite3, ATS or equivalent. >>>> >>>> Thanks, Vince >>>>